Perfect Peace

Teena Daize

TW: hymn lyrics, child safety, abuse allegation

_______________________________________________________

Oh for the peace…. The opening line of hymn 174. One of my favourites for 31 years. Today, for the first time in 2.5 years, I pulled the lyrics up on my phone.

Why? Because someone I used to be very close to has just come home from Seagrave, the first Ontario convention of the season and shared a post that says “I’m in love with this sentence: ‘Don’t let someone ruin your peace just because they can’t find theirs.’” In the comments, 2 other people I used to be very close to agreed wholeheartedly.

So I’ve been thinking about peace and all we would hear about it in meetings.

“Unwav’ring faith that never doubts.” Well, there’s a thought-stopping cliché if I ever heard one. I had doubts. And not just in 2023. I had doubts my whole professing life. So I did what all good 2x2s do. I prayed and questioned myself, my commitment, my love. I wondered why sometimes I couldn’t pray because no one was listening. There’s no greater condemnation than self-condemnation.

Then the hymn continues with a list of bests:

“Best, tho’ my plans be set at naught;

Best, tho’ the way be rough;

Best, tho’ my earthly store be scant;

In Thee I have enough.

Best, tho’ my health and strength be gone,

Tho’ weary days be mine;

Shut out from much that others have;

Not my will, Lord, but Thine.”

Which boil down to this: even though life really sucks sometimes, I’m going to stick my fingers in my ears and sing loudly no matter what it costs me mentally, emotionally, and yes, spiritually.

And then “Oh for the peace of a perfect trust, that looks away from all, yet sees Thy hand in everything. In great events and small.” This line right here is is cognitive dissonance at its finest. Have you seen the meme that says “It’s fine, I’m fine, everything is fine”? Everything is not fine. The hymn writer said looks away from all. But you do look, because how are you going to see God’s hand in it? Or you don’t look, and decades of legitimate reasons to look pile up, and a dead overseer in a hotel room reveals the rot in a system you believe is God’s way on earth. While you’re busy not looking, allegations pile up.

This past weekend at Seagrave, a man with many credible allegations was there. The red box was published on Thursday. Many of us forwarded it to people attending. And it felt like no one cared. Someone I sent it to responded, “Don’t send me messages like this. It’s not appreciated.” At a separate convention, someone posted a pic of a group of children all in their Sunday best while wolves in sheep’s clothing circle. “Oh for the peace of a perfect trust. A heart with Thee at rest.”

The hymn writer wants a perfect peace no matter the cost. I’m not looking for that kind of peace anymore. The cost was far too great. I would rather be awake and unsettled, angry, doubting, questioning, than asleep at the wheel, with perfect peace, moments away from a head-on collision.

Read Teena’s Substack article

Share the Post: