Mel’s post of DB’s sermon reminded me of a post I did a while back on what I call “worker speak”. There were several examples of this methodology in the first page of his sermon (as far as got through reading through it).
Here is my post again, in case that manner of preaching still has negative impact on your life:
Today, I feel moved to share some thoughts about Worker’s Preaching methods – How they work, and why they stress frequent attendance at “gospel” and convention services. And why at the end of a particular convention sermons you feel like you are coming out of a particular state, almost like a trance, and re-engaging with reality.
Others have mentioned how that when you listen critically you find that often the workers are not saying much of anything, and certainly not much that makes logical and straightforward sense. Yet, somehow their message can dig deep into minds and cause convicted beliefs, behavior changes, separation in families etc. And in combination with environmental influence these words can result in deep beliefs, deep seated fears of hell and “worldly influence”, and conviction that they are the only ones right with God. It can also result in much mental anguish and distress when a person realizes that they need to leave the sect for their own health, but still carry deep seated beliefs and indoctrinated fear embedded deep in their mind and body. How is this possible?
Certainly, the workers do not do straight talk in their preaching. Can you imagine someone new coming to a “Gospel” meeting and the worker saying: “So, what we are about is we are a 125 year old sect that developed as an anti-mainstream church way of worship. So we turn our noses up at church buildings, we disapprove of ministers who wear robes and jewelry and so on. We believe we are the only ones on the planet who are saved and everyone else is going to hell, although if you ask us that directly we will deny it. If you join us, you will never be quite sure of your salvation, we just want you to always be afraid you are not doing enough, so we teach that you do not know your fate until after you die. Oh, and by the way, if you want to hang around with us very long there are a few things you will need to change about yourself, you know, important things like hair, and dress, and makeup and jewelry, and please, please hide your TV. Oh, and we claim we never change, but we actually do (black stockings and shabby apparel haven’t been a requirement for a while now) but we do it gradually and without talking about it so that we can deny that change happens.”
After a few minutes of this the new person would shake their heads, roll their eyes and walk out, right? Their critical and logical brain would reject the concepts outright.
So, workers don’t speak straight. Instead, they use indirect suggestive language, mainly allegory, some metaphors, and lots of double-meaning words and suggestions, in little picture painting stories (“parables” to make them sound extra holy) that can often sound quite nice on the surface, but are loaded with additional meanings and subtle suggestions to the listener. Truth=truth but also =“our specific way of worship”, not taking a name =implication we don’t need to because we are the only right ones, “the way”=a path, but also the only exclusive club going about things in the approved way and having the potential to go to heaven, etc.
Think about all the double meanings you’ve come to understand from the oft used Sower & Seed parable that get planted in your brain; Sower=worker, seed=workers words, fertile ground =someone who accepts those words unquestioningly, stony ground =someone with doubts hindering them from accepting the workers message unreservedly, etc. From a linguistic-psychological perspective, what is happening here is that the allegory and double meaning words and phrases bypass our critical and conscious minds acting directly on our subconscious minds where deep seated beliefs also reside, those things we just know and believe without having to think about. The conscious mind hears a nice little story… the subconscious gets the message “join us or you are doomed”.
These happen to be the some of the same techniques that a hypnotist uses to make suggestions to us and bypass our conscious resistance and habitual thinking patterns. I have experienced the state of trance in other settings. As 1 example, I once participated in an African mixed instrument drumming circle where I was asked to drum the main beat on a large center drum. I agreed, and closed my eyes to absorb the changing sounds of the instruments circling around me for what felt like a few minutes before the session wrapped up. I was astounded when I realized that actually more than two hours had passed. After experiencing trance elsewhere I now recognize I have also been in a state of trance during certain moving convention meetings; you know the kind, where you can feel yourself emerging and re-engaging with the world around you afterwards. Think about a convention environment, the right cultural influences, the hushed reverence before meetings signaling your brain that something important is about to happen, the harmonic singing of incredibly suggestive words, all of this setting the stage for the message to follow to have maximum impact on our beliefs. Easy with a bit of suggestion for you to interpret what happens next during the sermon with “feeling the spirit” instead of the very natural human phenomenon it is, experienced by all humans in certain circumstances.
Despite it’s association with entertainment and general wierd phenomena, there is nothing inherently wrong nor magical about hypnosis and the state of trance, it’s something we all have experienced. It is simply a hyper focused attention – a half conscious state between sleeping and fully awake where the conscious mind is less active and ignores the majority of sensory input for a while. Many people have experienced hypnotherapy to be extremely helpful if performed with integrity and care. We also put ourselves into mild trances all the time (think about the times when someone asks you “where were you just now?”).
Indirect language influence is also commonly used in sales, in politics etc. But it can also be harmful, hypnotic language is a common tool used in dangerous mind control cults, and can be used to implant false memories by possibly well meaning, but unethical therapists.
It is clear that there are tons more things going on in our mind than just our stream of conscious thought. For a small example, as you are reading my words, subconsciously your mind is regulating your breathing and your movements, it is monitoring your environment, you are feeling emotions, your eyes and visual cortex are aware of much more than the screen you are reading, yet you were not really consciously aware of any of that unless something draws your attention to it. Like I just did.
If something suddenly moves or changes around you your subconscious signals your consciousness and your attention shifts to that stimulus to check it out.
The subconscious is also where many researchers believe your deep rooted beliefs and sense of self reside, the things you just know about yourself and the world around you without thinking about it. It’s connected to the lens of your experience and being that you perceive all physical inputs through. This is the area of mind that the indirect language speaks directly to, and where it can form new beliefs that suddenly you “just know to be so” and are convicted of, without really understanding how that actually happened.
Now go back to how I started this note…”I feel moved to…”. Without saying it directly, using double meaning words, I suggested that I had a message to share that was inspired by a being other than myself. And without thinking about it you knew exactly what I was implying, as you have been conditioned to understand the double meaning of those words in the 2×2 culture. See how it works? Workers speak like that all the time.
I suspect workers learn to do this from growing up with it, and from the examples of older workers. One former worker wrote on here how he was chastised by his companion for providing a needy fearful soul some straight positive talk about salvation. No straight talk please, only allegory.
I wonder how this started in the 2×2? The first workers didn’t take classes in linguistics, and mind influence psychology, but neither do cult leaders. They probably just learned it from other effective preachers, perfected it through trial and error, and passed it down. Use of suggestive language has a long history, far longer than any psychological understanding of it.
We also form our beliefs about the world and ourselves through life experiences, especially ones that are emotionally charged or traumatic where we make decisions on how we must be to survive physically and mentally in whatever future situation we find ourselves. This is partly why abuse and trauma experienced in childhood has such lasting impaon our sense of self and how to feel safe. We then often move on in life viewing every thing through the lens of those experiences and with beliefs about ourselves and how the world works and our behaviors influenced by decisions made during the worst moments of our life, the decisions themselves lost from conscious memory over time. Good therapy often works by helping us examine these subconscious decisions/beliefs to see if they are really serving us in a healthy way, and if not tries to help us change them to ones that serve us better.
So why do workers stress attendance at Gospel meetings and convention so much? Because breaks in attendance makes it so much easier to think critically and leave while frequent exposure to the same suggestions keeps them refreshed and effective and having power over us.
Just like living with a narcissist and exposed to constant comments might cause you to believe a lot of negative things about yourself that you would start to see through and doubt if you are away from them for a period of time. And like how cult members are sometimes rescued when some medical event or accident requires them to be physically away from the cult group giving others a chance to interact with them away from the reinforement of the immersive cult environment.
When you are away from meetings for a while and the constant reinforcement of the suggestions, they words start to seem more illogical and your critical mind can start taking the ideas out and examining and testing them. This is why often folks who stop attending meetings for a bit often end up leaving the 2×2’s, and why people found it easier to leave during the pandemic. Or should I call it “losing out” – just more double meaning words to help keep folks securely “in the fold”.
The 2×2 beliefs are not easy to dislodge as the suggestions implant beliefs deep in our brains, we are not conscious of how the beliefs got there and why we have them, rather, it becomes “what we just know to be so”. Also, as you know, the group generally discourages open discussion and examination of your beliefs, rather it is seen as better to “just have faith” and not “be questioning” so that critical thinking skills are not engaged. For born and raised members the language and beliefs form the environment of our mind’s development imbedding the beliefs firmly before we develop the ability to critically examine them. But now that you know a bit about it you can forgive yourself for the fears and questions that arise when you start to emerge from the 2×2 trance. You can understand that that feeling of “the spirit moving” is a natural phenomenon experienced by all humans in certain circumstances, but interpreted to reinforce different beliefs depending on cultural environment. (read Maslow’s “Religions, Values and Peak Experiences” if you like to see how people of all kinds of different faiths and beliefs feel incredible life and belief affirming moments).
And feel free to test some new beliefs and ways of being to see which ones serve you best, help you care for yourself, and help you be a caring citizen of the world interested in more than just your belief tribe.
Best of luck. May you be healthy and happy as you explore the freedom you always had, even though you may not have realized you had that power and were actually free all along.