1st Media Article in Netherlands

by Aaldert van Soest.

1st Article 

https://www.nd.nl/geloof/geloof/1252917/deze-sektarische-beweging-heeft-honderden-aanhangers-in-neder#closemodal

He has given up everything. From now on, he will own nothing, have no fixed residence, and, most painfully, he will lead a celibate life. Nathan* has become a “worker” in the closed faith community in which he grew up. Together with an older companion, he is sent out to preach the gospel, both to people within the community and to outsiders.

This is part 1 of a two-part series. Part 2 will appear next week. Read at the bottom of this article why and how we conducted this investigation.

One year he is sent here, another year there. The Netherlands is divided into several “fields” for this purpose. He stays with so-called friends. This has been the way of life in this community for many years: he has no influence over it, especially not as a young worker. Nathan accepts it all, because for him the goal is sacred: this is the ultimate way to dedicate his life to God.

But the reality is disappointing, he says, looking back on that period, more than fifteen years ago. “We did tea visits, and occasionally led a gathering. That was it. We barely had meaningful conversations about faith. Those were not appreciated. And I had given up my entire life for that.”

One person who is willing to tell his story with his full name is Richard Boom: “Gladly even, they should know who they are up against.”

When he starts asking critical questions, a conversation follows with the then-head worker, during which Bible verses are thrown at him, and he is accused of being insolent. The leadership then pairs him with another senior worker. This is someone who, due to previous misconduct, is not supposed to be traveling with younger men—and this is known. Nathan is convinced this was meant as punishment for his critical questions. “They did everything to break me,” he says. Eventually, he ends up at home with a severe burnout.

Nathan’s story is not unique. There are former workers with similar experiences. “I was so belittled by an older companion that at one point I started taking sleeping pills during the day just to endure it,” Tim recalls.

“I had to ask him permission for everything, even to open a car window. During visits, he wanted me to stay silent and listen to him. He called people of color ‘blackies.’ And during a conversation, he said that people of color were a mistake in creation. As a person of color, I had to listen to that. These are all small acts of bullying, but when you are never allowed to confront your older companion about it, it becomes too much.” At the same time, he had a deep religious conviction during that period: for this work, he had to be willing to endure anything.

FBI Investigation in America

The community, which has followers worldwide (estimates range from 150,000 to 250,000), remained completely under the radar for a long time. That changed a year and a half ago when stories emerged in the United States about large-scale child sexual abuse within this movement. Media outlets published reports, a victim hotline was set up (which now has 910 alleged perpetrators in sight), and the FBI launched an investigation in America.

In the Netherlands—and elsewhere on mainland Europe—however, the silence has been deafening, even though the movement also has hundreds of followers in our country. The Nederlands Dagblad investigated the Dutch branch of this Two by Two movement. From conversations with dozens of involved individuals, a picture emerges of a very closed community with deeply devout members. Former members almost universally describe being harmed, isolated, and instilled with fear. Some of them also report sexual abuse (more on this in a second article about this movement).

“We needed salvation, and it could only be obtained through the Two by Two Church”

Most former members do not want their (full) names published in the newspaper. The reason is that they still have family members in the faith community and are afraid that relationships will be jeopardized. Richard Boom, however, is willing to share his story openly: “Gladly, they should know who they’re up against.”

He is furious at the movement he joined as a child with his mother, who, in his opinion, is still under its control. She married someone from the community in the early 1990s. Richard was 16 years old at the time. He is completely done with what is, to him, clearly a sect (see sidebar: Is this a sect?). As a teenager, he already doubted the message he heard but was simultaneously afraid that his doubts would send him to hell. “We were supposed to be a chosen people. Everything would be fine as long as you kept attending the services.”

Fear of God’s Punishment

Fear of God’s punishment is a theme that frequently comes up in these conversations. “In the services, it was often said that you could be lost,” Julia* recalls. That fear would stay with her for a long time—even after she had left the community. Linda recognizes this. “We were constantly told how weak and sinful we are as humans,” she says. “So, we needed salvation, and it could only be obtained through the Two by Two Church.” When she decided to leave the community, her mother called her in tears, saying, “Child, now you’re going to hell.” Even now, more than 20 years later, she finds it very emotional to look back on.

Leaving is difficult, she explains. “You completely lose the connection to the life you had built.”

Similarities to the Reformed Tradition

Those who come from the Reformed world will recognize much in this community. The rules and outward appearances resemble the way conservative Reformed (refo) individuals live: women with long hair and skirts, no jewelry, no television. At the same time, there are differences. Reformed believers typically belong to larger and more recognizable churches. They also have their own schools, institutions, media, and platforms for exchanging opinions. The Two by Two movement operates more under the radar. Nothing is set in stone because only the Bible counts, and there is resistance to books about faith. All guidelines are unwritten and are communicated through the workers, who consequently seem to have an even greater position of power than Reformed pastors in their world. More on this power dynamic later.

Secrecy About History

When did the movement originate? That question leads back to Ireland, at the end of the 19th century. In this region, evangelist William Irvine separated himself from the missionary movement Faith Mission and started something new. A central role for him was a passage from Matthew 10, which describes Jesus sending his disciples out two by two.

This historical account is only sparsely known among current followers of the faith community. Most former members only heard about it later in life or discovered it through their own research. “I was told back then that this was a fabricated story,” says Joosje.

Why the secrecy about the history? It may be related to the controversial figure of William Irvine himself. In 1914, he was excommunicated because he increasingly elevated his own status and had affairs with women. Another frequently mentioned reason is that acknowledging an origin in the 19th century undermines the exclusivity of the community. Within the Two by Two movement, there is a belief that it began when Jesus sent his disciples into the world in pairs. From that moment on, this truth is said to have been passed down orally from generation to generation. An “origin” in the 19th century would disrupt that direct line from Jesus’ disciples to the present.

Those who left the community were “cut off from the body of Christ,” says Luuk.*

“I was told as a child that the Catholic Church was a split from our faith,” says Linda. “There was also a lot of criticism of church buildings, with all their splendor and pomp.”

The community itself meets on Sunday mornings in private homes. Incidentally, it deliberately has no official name. After all, when Jesus sent out his disciples, that movement also had no name, goes the reasoning. Former members sometimes refer to it as “the service.” Following international publications, this article uses the term Two by Two movement.

“Prepared for the Battle”

It is Sunday, July 21, 2024. Around 300 Two by Two followers have gathered this weekend for their annual conference. Another weekend will follow the week after. Women wear skirts, and most men wear long pants and shirts. At the end of the afternoon, everyone gathers in a large tent for the evening service of that day. There are people of all ages in the tent, including at least ten to twenty small children. Some people wear earpieces: they are guests from abroad who are having Dutch translated for them.

As the murmuring subsides, there is a cappella singing from the community’s own hymnbook. There are also prayers and two speeches. The second is delivered by Bart Hartemink, the head worker in the Netherlands. He walks through the entire Bible: from Zacchaeus to Jacob and Esau, from Elijah to Jesus with his disciples, and then back to Job. The common thread: God has a plan for everyone’s life. He concludes with the armor of God (Ephesians 6) and the importance of prayer. Because not only does God have a plan, but we also need a plan, he argues. “We must be prepared for the battle.”

A closing hymn follows:

“The will of God is always good / And brings His blessing / If we surrender our plans / Then His peace will descend on us.”

After the service, the Nederlands Dagblad approaches Hartemink, who leads the community in the Netherlands. He agrees to an interview, which takes place later that week with him and his colleague worker Martin Roest in a restaurant along the A28. When asked whether only followers of this faith community go to heaven, Hartemink responds negatively: “Salvation can only be attained through Jesus, and we do not have a monopoly on Jesus.”

“I was not allowed to think for myself. I see that as spiritual abuse.”

Still, almost all former members say they were taught something different in the past. Marlies: “We were the only ones, the little lights in the dark world. There might have been a single lost sheep of Jesus in another church. But that definitely did not apply to that church as a whole, because those people would then be drawn to the service.”

Those who left the community were “cut off from the body of Christ,” says Luuk*. He vividly remembers a moment during a Sunday morning service. “A woman said, ‘Anyone who leaves this community is cursed.’ It’s not that everyone thinks like that. But she was also not contradicted.”

“It’s fair to say that some think this way,” Hartemink acknowledges. “But it’s not true. We don’t have a monopoly on the truth; no one does.”

Sexual Misconduct

Back to Nathan’s story. When he asked critical questions, he was paired with an (already deceased) older companion who, due to sexual misconduct, should no longer have been sent out with a young man. The intention, Nathan believes, was to teach him a lesson, and the current head workers readily admit this. Roest: “That should never have happened.”

There was no sexual abuse in that relationship because Nathan gave his older companion no opportunity. “I wasn’t having it and was a head taller. But he did make all kinds of insinuations.” A second article in this investigative series will delve deeper into sexual abuse and the role this older worker played in it.

However, Nathan sees himself as a victim of abuse of power and spiritual coercion. This applies not only to his time as a young worker but also to the periods before and after. “I was not allowed to think for myself,” he summarizes. “Whether it was about certain customs, appearances, or, more importantly, the way the Bible was interpreted, the rules of the workers were given more importance in the community than God’s word. From a young age, I learned that questioning the ideology and practices of the workers was not allowed. I see that as spiritual abuse.”

A former member from abroad, now a therapist specializing in domestic violence and child protection, says that since the publicity in America, many former members of the faith community have approached her. According to her, their stories reveal a pattern of emotional and spiritual abuse. “Especially the misuse of Bible verses to make a point or silence dissenting opinions.”

Resistance to Critical Questions

This difficulty with critical questions is also evident in another episode. Around 2020, a group of critical members within the Two by Two movement formed, calling themselves Siloam. They wrote a letter to the then-head worker in the Netherlands, Hendrik Ferreira, and two other European head workers, also known as overseers (Ben Crompton from the United Kingdom and Peter Zürcher from Switzerland). In it, they raised various questions about the rules or, in their view, radical positions, such as the refusal to baptize certain individuals or the prohibition of television.

“You are building this relationship on a completely wrong foundation.”

In their reply, which is in the possession of this newspaper, the overseers made it clear to the members of Siloam that they expected their obedience and loyalty. For example, in a passage about baptism, it was revealed that workers sometimes decide that someone is not yet ready to be baptized. “We as workers may not always make the decision you as friends would make, but the person concerned (the one to be baptized, ed.) will never suffer loss if that decision is accepted.”

Elsewhere in the reply, they discussed the Wednesday evening gatherings. “We all want to be encouraged, admonished, or corrected, don’t we? These gatherings should not be changed into meetings for discussing topics or raising personal matters.”

The overseers from the United Kingdom, Switzerland, and Germany took it even further in a 2023 letter, in which questions were raised about the appointment of Bart Hartemink as leader in the Netherlands. Ordinary members were not to interfere in that process. “The changing of an overseer has always been left to the older workers by the friends,” they wrote. “You may disagree with this, as well as with our interpretation of Acts 15 and 16, but we will not discuss this further.”

In an interview with this newspaper, head workers Hartemink and Roest admitted that workers within the community have sometimes abused their power. “That’s not what we stand for,” they emphasize. “In Acts 15, it states that the elders and the entire church made a decision together. Unfortunately, you have to acknowledge that this has not always been the case with us.”

An Example of Abuse of Power

Another example of abuse of power is a correspondence between a prominent worker and a young woman. She had entered into a relationship with someone outside the community and, partly because of this, no longer attended Sunday services. An older worker contacted her about this. He wrote that the friends and the workers together form “the body of Christ” and that her choice for her boyfriend was essentially a choice against Jesus. “You are building this relationship on a completely wrong foundation,” he added. “If you continue with this, you will face a difficult life.”

“Terrible,” Roest acknowledges. “We may advise people if they ask for it, but we cannot enforce anything.”

Appreciation for Simplicity

There is also another perspective: that of devout people who belong to this community with heart and soul, for whom the critical media attention is painful. At the request of the community itself, this newspaper spoke with a group of seven loyal members. Each of them describes how precious the community is to them. They hear God’s voice in it, feel His Spirit, and experience security and connection with one another.

The Sunday morning house meetings (see also sidebar) are particularly important to them. They appreciate the “simplicity” of the community. “Precisely because it’s not about a name, a building, or a payroll of employees, something else becomes central,” one of them says. “Namely, the connection with God.”

Whether their community is the only true one, they dare not say. “It’s not for us to determine.” However, in this conversation, it is mentioned twice that this community is “closest to the Bible.” That doesn’t mean, though, that everything has to stay the same. This community also evolves, they emphasize. “My daughters simply wear pants when workers are at the house.”

This last comment refers to the mandatory rules and appearances that many former members struggled with: clothing rules, no makeup, no attending school parties. “At one point, we were even told we couldn’t read comic books anymore,” Joosje recalls. “I found that awful because I devoured Donald Duck comics.”

“They spat at me and called me a filthy skirt-wearer.”

These rules were emphasized, and women were especially targeted. Several sources independently mention former head worker Piet Blokker, who gave speeches about clothing prescriptions. “It was 30 degrees, but even three-quarter sleeves weren’t allowed,” Richard says. Several women also recount being reprimanded by workers for the length of their skirts or sleeves. Angela* remembers coming home from school gym class wearing jeans. Workers were visiting at the time. “I planned to change at home. But one of the workers, seeing me in pants, started crying because of it. That made me feel guilty at the time.”

At school—most attended public or broad Christian education—they often faced challenges due to their faith background. Many former members describe instances of bullying, with women experiencing it the most. “They spat at me and called me a filthy skirt-wearer,” says Julia.

The bullying was less common when the children led a double life. “At school, I was someone different than at home or in the service. I couldn’t reconcile those worlds,” says Auke*.

Tim, on the other hand, took his faith so seriously as a child that, starting in fifth grade, he consciously behaved differently from his classmates. “I didn’t laugh at jokes, didn’t go to birthday parties, didn’t participate in extracurricular activities, and avoided crushes. I even felt guilty if I fit in with the group because I had to be ‘different.’” When they talked about it, children were told they had to endure the bullying. “It was part of it. You would be rewarded for it in heaven.”

Worker Martin Roest finds it distressing to hear stories of bullying. At the same time, he adds, that’s the reality in schools. “I don’t want to downplay it, but children can be harsh to one another. The fact that you’re a Christian can be a reason to be mocked.” He experienced this himself in elementary school. “But fortunately, my parents handled it very well at the time.”

From Farmers to Scientists

The Two by Two community is very diverse in terms of background and educational level: from farmers to scientists, from construction workers to a pilot, a manager in the financial sector, or a spokesperson in political The Hague. Of course, not all of them are yes-men to the workers. The international media attention has caused significant unrest and discussion internally, and some have dropped out.

The head workers state that about 600 people in the Netherlands are still connected to the community (“though we don’t keep a membership list”), but some former members estimate that the number has since dwindled to around 400.

“I had to rediscover my entire identity as a Christian.”

Some former members came out relatively unscathed, while others say they still suffer from it—even after many hours of therapy. “It took me years to break free from the influence of this group,” says Auke. “And when I hear songs from the hymnbook, an irrational fear still comes over me.”

Some former members ended up in a more open Christian congregation, where a new faith world opened up for them. “I had to rediscover my entire identity as a Christian,” says Sanne*. She points out that within the faith community, it is not taught that Jesus is God, which she finds particularly troubling. “As a result, I never truly understood the Christian gospel.”

Others have abandoned all forms of religion or found an alternative way of believing. Auke says, “I can no longer relate to the biblical image of God. It’s been destroyed because I associate it with that time and that group.”

The names Nathan, Julia, Angela, Luuk, Auke, and Sanne are fictitious. The other first names in the article are real. All full names are known to the editorial team.

Two by Two Movement in Five Characteristics

■ Workers and Friends

The members of the community are called “friends.” They are not officially members anywhere. The preachers are called “workers.” They give up all their possessions, must live a celibate life, and are sent in pairs to a region, where they usually stay with friends. Women can also become workers (so-called “sister workers”), but the leader of a country or region (the “overseer”) is always a man.

■ Baptism and Making “the Choice”

There are two moments when people can consciously connect to the community. At a young age, one can make “the choice.” This means standing up in a special meeting to declare a commitment to God and this community. This often happens at a relatively young age: between 8 and 12 years old. Additionally, friends are baptized as “adults,” but usually, they are still teenagers. This always takes place during the annual conference.

■ Different Services

The heart of the community is the Sunday morning service. Around ten to twelve people gather in a private home. There, they sing, pray, and those who have made “the choice” share something from the Bible. Communion is celebrated every Sunday. There are also “gospel services” on Sunday evenings or during the week. These are led by workers and take place in small halls. Although not much advertising is done, these services are open to outsiders. In the summer, there is a conference for the entire community in the Netherlands.

■ Finances and Foundation

The workers live without possessions and are supported by the friends. Although workers have bank accounts, support is typically provided through envelopes containing cash. Around the annual conference, workers hand in what they have “left over,” and each worker starts again with an amount sufficient for the first period of living expenses. The movement is difficult to trace—there is no website or clear address—but Nederlands Dagblad discovered the Stichting Algemeen Beheer Baten en Verkrijgingen (General Management and Proceeds Foundation) after investigation. This foundation manages funds for those called to “do the evangelistic work as intended in, among others, Matthew 10” (the chapter where Jesus sends his disciples two by two, ed.). The foundation manages funds from inheritances, among other sources, but it is unclear how much money is involved. There are no indications that people profit financially from it.

■ International Character

The Two by Two movement is a worldwide faith community. There are countries with many followers (such as Scotland, Ireland, the United States, and Australia), but it is found in numerous countries and on every continent. Conferences are organized in all these countries or regions, which are also attended by many foreign workers and friends. The community has a relatively high number of international marriages, as people sometimes find a foreign life partner from within their own faith community in this way.

Is this a cult?

Publications in the media often refer to the Two by Two movement as a cult (in English, sect or cult). Although this article does not make that classification itself, several characteristics of a sectarian movement are evident, says Arjan van Dijk after reading this article. Van Dijk previously worked for the government agency Sektesignaal and now assists the expertise center Fier in setting up a new support service for cults and closed groups.

Experts identify five main characteristics, Van Dijk explains: excessive devotion, a closed nature, authoritarian leadership, coercive control over members, and harm to individuals or society. Some characteristics, such as the closed nature and excessive devotion, are clearly present. For other characteristics—such as authoritarian leadership—the picture is more ambivalent.

The more cults or groups meet the five mentioned characteristics, the more often misconduct occurs, says Van Dijk. This can involve criminal acts such as sexual abuse, financial exploitation, labor exploitation, or denial of medical care. It can also involve psychological misconduct, such as alienating family or friends, denying individuality, suppressing critical thinking, manipulation, and group pressure. “Even in the ongoing research we’re conducting at Fier in preparation for the new support service, we encounter these issues.”

About This Investigation

Why did we investigate this?

In international media, such as the Associated Press (AP) and the British broadcaster BBC, alarming reports about the Two by Two movement have surfaced over the past year and a half. Former members came forward with harrowing stories of spiritual and sexual abuse. However, these articles did not address the situation in the Netherlands or mainland Europe, even though the movement also has followers in these regions.

After contact with a former member, Nederlands Dagblad decided to investigate to uncover possible misconduct in the Netherlands. By doing so, we aim to give potential victims a voice by hearing their stories and making issues open for discussion. The dynamics within the Two by Two movement are also relevant to a broader audience. The Netherlands is estimated to have between 80 and 250 cults or closed religious communities. Moreover, some of the dynamics, such as abuse of power and spiritual coercion, are also visible in mainstream churches.

How did we investigate this?

For this investigation, Nederlands Dagblad conducted extensive interviews with fourteen Dutch former members of the Two by Two movement. The responsible workers were also interviewed, and a group discussion was held with seven current members.

Internationally, several books about the movement have been published, mostly written by former members. The only Dutch-language publications about this community are by Jildert de Boer, who, as an outsider, followed the community closely for a period. His books were consulted for this article, and ND also spoke directly with De Boer. Finally, the newspaper spoke with foreign individuals involved, including the American founders of a reporting center for sexual abuse within this movement.

Share the Post: