Presented June 24, 2026 by
Crystal Stiles Mandt, Cynthia Dykstra Liles, Cherie
Kropp and Bruce Murdoch
We created this presentation because accountability begins with actual “Truth”. For too long, survivors’ voices have been dismissed while documented evidence has remained scattered, ignored, or misunderstood. Our goal is not to attack faith or sincere people, but to gather the available documentation in one place so others can examine it for themselves, ask informed questions, and decide what they believe based on evidence rather than rumor or fear.
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men and women to do nothing!
IRA HOBBS
Ira Hobbs was born March 10, 1933, in Kentucky and is currently 93 yrs old. There were 9 Hobbs children (6 sons, 3 daughters). 4 became workers; 2 became state overseers; all but 2 sons professed. The Hobbs family moved from KY to Memphis TN around 1934 and were considered “royalty.” Ira entered the work in TN and was also in the work in Georgia, Florida, Ohio, Colorado, Kentucky, Louisiana and Texas.
1960 to 1968 – Jean Trotter Austin was born on January 28, 1952, in Georgia, born and raised in meetings, and professed at age 12. Growing up she never felt loved or normal and was vulnerable to being abused.
Ira Hobbs repeatedly sexually abused Jean beginning when she was 8-9 yrs old, in the third grade (1960-61. Jean disclosed that while Ira was playing Scrabble with her and her family, and also sometimes when they were eating at the table, he would put his hand up her dress and into her panties under the table.This has been his M.O. for some other young girls. One girl when they were giving thanks at convention preps! Another while “helping” with her homework.
Another while she was driving him somewhere.
After Jean’s parents went to bed, Ira would molest her. It was very painful; she would beg him to stop and he would just laugh. Her father caught Ira molesting her one time, and called her a dirty flirt and a streetwalker. Jean was crushed, as she was just doing what the worker told her to do, which was what her parents had taught her to do. When she was 13, she started crying constantly and was uncontrollable. Her mother took her to several psychiatrists–she may have had a mental breakdown. She became promiscuous. Some professing boys found this out and pretended to like her. Ira continued to abuse her until she was about 16 and he was sent to Florida around 1967-68.
Please read Jean’s heart rending story: https://ex2x2.info/2020/11/06/austin-jean-trotter/
1970s – Sister workers reported sexual assaults by Hobbs to senior brother workers.
1980s – Dale Gardner communicated repeatedly with Overseer Taylor Woods, as well as other workers, and pleaded with them to remove Hobbs from the work, as Hobbs had abused Dale’s daughter, and he had learned of the abuse of others by Hobbs as well. He also discussed the sex abuse of children and women by workers Horace Burgess, Roy Dietzel and Kenneth Wahlin – and the fact that the ministry was well aware, and they were simply moved around to different geographical areas. Worker Murray Keene told Dale that “he was out of place in these matters,” and was told to quit talking about the abuse.
Dale’s uncle Tom, a worker in Canada, was sent to speak with him. Tom told him that “this happened many times in Canada, and that the girls get over it and ‘we’ can’t put the workers out, because we have so few workers and need them so bad. Dale’s brother told him, “The only thing worse than men who represent themselves as ministers of God, and molest children, is a group of Christian people who allow such evil men to continue as ministers of the group.” We agree. Dale didn’t shut up and was subsequently excommunicated.
Please read Dale’s letters for yourself: https://wingsfortruth.info/2023/07/08/35-years-ago-to-taylor-wood-and-the-church/
After Ira had preached in Colorado from 1974-1987, after Dale Gardner’s ruckus there, Ira was moved to Kentucky for 1988 to 1989; then to Louisiana from 1990 to 1997; and to Texas for 1998-2008. In 2000, Ira was made overseer of Texas & New Mexico, after Wiliam Lewis died.
In March 2003, Jean was diagnosed with stage 3 breast cancer, had a radical mastectomy and reconstruction. Chemo, radiation and other treatments made her overweight, bald, very sick and depressed. She started seeing a therapist for her depression who questioned Jean about her childhood, homelife, religion and other things.
2006: Jean confided that she had been sexually molested by a preacher for 7-8 years of her childhood. The therapist was very kind and helpful. She encouraged Jean to let go of the burdens of her past by writing a letter to her Abuser.
So, 40 years after the abuse happened, Jean wrote a letter “letting it all hang out,” telling how Ira Hobbs had ruined her life and about all the misery she has suffered and railing out about his faults, poor personal hygiene, etc.—but she didn’t have his address to mail it. So she googled his name and found it mentioned on the Truth-Meeting Message Board. Without knowing anything about the board, she posted her letter on it on September 17, 2006. View Letter: https://ex2x2.info/2020/11/06/austin-jean-trotter/
WELL! Her letter caused a HUGE stir. Replies on the Message Board filled up several pages, and her letter somehow made its way to Ira. A month later, on October 18, 2006, Ira wrote Jean an apology. View Apology: https://ex2x2.info/2020/11/06/austin-jean-trotter/
Jean didn’t consider it much of an apology—said his letter was all about him and contained lies.
He wrote: “I recognized that in my association with you, there was too much human interest that diminished from my purpose of promoting spiritual growth. There were times that my behavior with you was not the ideal actions of a servant of God because of carelessness and casualness that developed.”
When I (Cherie Kropp) read Jean’s letter on the Truth-Message Board (aka TMB), I immediately recalled meeting Jean and her parents in June 1964, when both our families happened to be in Florida vacationing at the same time. I contacted Jean and encouraged her to write her story; told her she might find it therapeutic for herself and others. I offered to help her write it. Using only email, Jean wrote me bits and pieces of her life history over several months, and I wove them into a chronological account that I posted online in my website Expressions.
Read Story: https://ex2x2.info/2020/11/06/austin-jean-trotter/
In 2007, within a year after Jean posted her letter, the WINGS for Truth group was formed and launched their website featuring Jean’s life story. They began advocating on Jean’s behalf to get Hobbs removed from the work. They located other girls he had abused and presented the “case” to the Eastern US overseer, Barry Barkley. Later, Ray Hoffman told Jean that one reason the workers believed her story was because of her description of Ira’s private parts—that someone else had described them the same way.
2007 – In October 2007, a year after Jean’s letter went public, Ray Hoffmann was installed as the overseer of Texas and New Mexico with Hobbs demoted to his under-companion.
2008 – On May 13, 2008, Hobbs was expelled from the work. How the mighty are fallen…
Reportedly, Ray gave Ira $100,000 when he left. In 2009, Ira married Joan (Wilson) Stephens, an ex-sister worker, widow in the church and they moved to Missouri.
2008 – Joe Trapp, a 2×2 Texan man, interceded for Jean. He pressured Ray Hoffman to make it right with Jean’s father who didn’t believe she was abused, and she badly wanted her family to believe her. Ray asked Joe, “What do you think would satisfy Jean?” Joe mentioned admission, public apology, Ira stepping down, making things right with her family, etc. Ray replied he thought $10,000 might satisfy her—that he knew she probably needed help with medical expenses.
2008 – On July 7, 2008, Ray Hoffman accompanied by Charles Vaughn (Overseer of Georgia) met with Jean’s parents and Jean. At the end, Ray gave Jean a brown paper bag with $10,000 cash. Jean was upset and felt like it was “quit-talking-about-it” money. Joe told her that she should definitely not feel like she needed to be quiet about it. Ray also called Jean’s brother who was unable to attend the meeting.
2008 – On May 30, 2008, Ray Hoffman – Overseer of Texas – distributed a notification letter to all the friends in Texas stating that he wished to end the “speculation and rumors” as to why Ira Hobbs was no longer in the work. He openly stated that Ira was under investigation for child sexual abuse issues and that several women had made complaints. The letter can be read here: https://wingsfortruth.info/breaking-the-silence-2/letters-to-friends-and-workers/ray-hoffman/
Reportedly, Ray compared his sending out of the notification letter about Ira’s CSA as being comparable to the Levite cutting his abused and murdered concubine into twelve pieces and sending her pieces throughout the country of Israel (Judges 19). A former worker commented
that Ray’s comparison seemed as if he considered Ira Hobbs the victim, and that he was very sorry he had to make Ira’s sins openly known to the church—rather than having true empathy and care for the survivors who suffered Ira’s abuse.
(Currently Jean’s health is in poor condition. Her surgery in the Fall of 2024 removed a large brain tumor that left her wheelchair bound, unable to speak, yet able to feed herself with effort, residing in an Assisted Living facility. She’s now 74 yrs old.)
2019 – Sister worker Katie Kiem was placed in Hobbs’ home on special meeting rounds. After staying overnight in the Hobbs’ home, she experienced medical complications and sought help. Medical professionals determined she had been drugged with Rohypnol and sexually assaulted,
which was reported to law enforcement, and an investigation was opened. https://wingsfortruth.info/2023/11/08/workers-expose-perpetrators-lies-and-provide-support-to-th e-survivor/
2019 – The owners of Clever, Missouri Convention banned Hobbs from attending convention. Reportedly, the Townsend’s had no idea Hobbs was under investigation for an alleged sex assault. https://ex2x2.info/2026/04/15/townsends-to-hobbs/
2021 – Even after Katie Kiem’s case was known to the workers, gospel meetings were held in Hobbs’ home. Hobbs Gospel Meetings 2021.pdf
2024– And even after the sex abuse crisis in the church was brought to light, and the FBI had announced its investigation into the church, meetings continued to be held in Hobbs’ home. Hobbs 2021 Letter Re Meetings.pdf
2026 – Katie Kiem died May 23, 2026 of cancer. Ira Hobbs has been under investigation in Missouri since 2019, and since 2023 with the FBI; it is our understanding that he remains under investigation by the FBI.
Katie’s obituary: https://www.feuerbornfuneral.com/obituaries/katie-keim
RUBEN MATA
1996 – Child sex abuse by worker Ruben Mata was reported to a brother worker. No action was taken.
1996-1999 – Another case of child sex abuse was reported to workers. No action was taken. 1999 – A third case of child sex abuse was reported to workers. No action was taken.
2000 – The allegations finally made their way to Overseer Dick Middleton, who confronted Ruben Mata, and Mata stepped down from the ministry. Apparently elder Ray Bullock (a Tulare County employee) and worker Steve Pierson accompanied Mata to the Tulare District Attorney’s
Office in California and Mata confessed. Apparently Tulare County filed courtesy reports with other counties and told Mata and his advocates to wait for a phone call.
2000 – 2006 – The workers informed no one that they were aware Mata had abused many boys. He continued to attend all meetings including special meetings and conventions.
2006 – Mata was reported to law enforcement in Santa Clara County, California and he was arrested. The ministry could no longer keep a lid on the Mata abuse. Dale Shultz distributed a letter to his staff along with a letter “To Whom It May Concern” which disclosed that Mata had been sexually abusing boys for a period of at least 20 years. Shultz’s letters made it obvious that damage control was their first priority. He instructed his staff to only show the letter to people who asked about Mata’s abuse, and to not leave copies of it with anyone – and that there may be rare cases in which it may be useful to show it to someone who is not professing – possibly a victim – HOWEVER, they should check with Dale or someone before they use it that way.
In addition, Dale stated, “We will ask you not to make any copies of this letter. To have one letter available in each field is certainly adequate. If we are not particularly careful with letters such as this, they can end of on [sic] an internet site for all the world to read. Also, to show this letter to people who do not need to see it may arouse concerns that they had not previously entertained. The purpose of the letter is to help those who have concerns, not to advertise a kingdom problem to those who either do not know about it or are not having a problem with it.”
The guidelines that Shultz distributed to his staff at the time made it clear that the ministry’s preferred style of reporting is an option that would actually not require them to report.
To be clear, clergy were mandated reporters in California in 2006, and confirmation of abuse was not required. Reporters were to report whenever they had “reasonable suspicion” that abuse had occurred. “Reasonable suspicion” means “that it is objectively reasonable for a person to entertain a suspicion, based upon facts that could cause a reasonable person in a Minor Consent, Confidentiality, and Child Abuse Reporting in California 17 like position, drawing, when appropriate, on his or her training and experience, to suspect child abuse or neglect.” Cal. Penal Code § 11166(a)(1).
2014 – A Mata survivor contacted his family to try to get help in working through his trauma. The workers were consulted, and the family pressed the ministry to make a public moral statement. The ministry responded that they could not make a moral statement due to their enemies.
December 2014 – Shultz writes an email to his advisors discussing the above victim and his family, and that the family, “‘is on a mission’ to obtain some definite assurance that steps are being taken to lessen the probability of such events ever happening again.” Shultz states that we, “See this as an overreaction on the part of the parents and do not have any plan to carry that out.” The letter is heavy on damage control verbiage and nonexistent on any showing of care or sympathy to survivors or their families or accountability.
In the end, the family was told by the workers that God did not speak to them. The family left meetings.
Mata was sentenced to 36 years to life. He was not eligible for parole. Mata died in prison on October 2, 2007.
Dale’s 2006 letters to his staff and the friends:
Dale’s 2006 Guidelines:
Letter from the father of a Ruben Mata survivor: Letter from a Father of a Ruben Mata Survivor.pdf
Shultz’s letter to his advisors regarding survivor and his family: Dale Shultz 2014 Letter_Redacted.pdf
NOEL TANNER
1970s – Tanner abused multiple boys in Northern Ireland, including Robert Kee, and parents reported to the workers in 1976. No action was taken, except that Tanner was moved from Northern Ireland to the Irish Republic, out of the reach of the Northern Ireland police. He remained in the work.
1980s – A non 2×2 reported Tanner to the police and he was convicted of sex offenses in December of 1984, at which time he was finally taken off of workers’ lists.
1990s – Tanner was again convicted of additional sex crimes against kids.
1994 – Robert Kee’s parents were excommunicated because they had a TV in their home. Robert is aware of 12 to 15 of other Tanner survivors, and we believe his victim count could be in the 100’s.
Please read the complete account here: https://wingsfortruth.info/breaking-the-silence-convicted-csa-offenders-noel-tanner/
PAUL GINESTAR
Rebecca Ginestar, was a Baldwin baby born June 8, 1969 who was adopted by former workers, Paul and Helen Ginestar. She was 14 before she discovered who she really was—the daughter of a Texas sister worker, Katherine Crane, who was allegedly raped while laboring in Mexico.
She was the youngest of their four adopted children.
Rebecca and her sister both professed at the same time in a meeting; she was 7 and her sister was 8. They did it to please their parents. Rebecca couldn’t even read her Bible at that time.
Paul Ginestar was the elder of both Sunday and Wednesday meetings, and he built a dormitory for the workers on his property. Paul Ginestar sexually abused his two daughters from the time they were toddlers into their teenage years, and over time, also abused three other young girls. When the workers came, Paul would proudly show them his collection of paddles, switches and whips hanging on the wall and boast, “That’s how we control the children.” The children were allowed to choose their choice of pain. When one of them got in trouble—often all four got a spanking.
In 1993, after reading my life story (Cherie Kropp) in the book Reflections, Rebecca called and told me about her shocking life. After graduating high school, she left meetings and married a divorced man; they had two small children. When she wanted to re-profess, sister worker Karen Oakes told her ONLY if she divorced her husband would she have a chance of getting to Heaven and be able to participate in meetings. So, she divorced him.
After she had paid the price of $9,000 for her salvation/divorce, she soon learned that wasn’t enough to even get her the privilege of speaking in meetings! After the first meeting she participated in, at a convention, sister worker Joyce Szakacs grabbed her arm and said, “Don’t you think you should wait to take part until you are told you can? I really think it would be better if you waited a year.”
Later, Rebecca, a single mother of 2, found herself in a desperate financial situation and needed money FAST for food, utilities, mortgage, etc. As a last resort, she went to work for a month as an exotic dancer. She danced all Saturday night and then cried all through meeting on Sunday. I strongly encouraged her to write her life story—that it would be therapeutic for her and would help others. However, I ended up ghost-writing it for her by transcribing her phone calls that I tape recorded. So that is why I am telling this part about her abuser, her father.
When Rebecca first disclosed her abuse to a professing confidant, she was not believed. Later, she reported it to worker John Sterling, who was very close to their family. John’s response was, “As you know, ‘the truth’ is not orthodox, Becki, and this could destroy ‘the truth’ as you know it. So we have to be careful that this information does not get into the wrong hands.”
February 5, 1996, Ex-2×2 Bob Daniel heard of Ginestar’s abuse and contacted the Oregon Overseer, Harold Bennett, expressing his concern, as he had family members who attended Ginestar’s meeting. He strongly encouraged the matter be referred to appropriate law agencies, and gave Bennett ten days to do so before Bob would take action.
March 4, 1996, Bennett replied: “You should know that he [Paul Ginestar] has been relieved of his Eldership, and that the church that once met in his home has been moved to another location. The sister workers have spent quite a lot of time visiting the saints in the area so that they will also be aware of the nature of Paul’s offenses. And he has been seeing a counselor to seek to obtain the needed professional therapy for help to rise above his problem. In accordance with Oregon law, the counselor has notified the appropriate authorities of the situation.”
Bob Daniels Letter to Harold Bennett.pdf
Harold Bennett Letter to Bob Daniels.pdf
Fellowship meetings were removed from his home; however, he was still allowed to attend all meetings, including special meetings and conventions and to take part in them. Rebecca observed her father grooming a young girl from a professing family and became very concerned. Because the workers failed to warn all the Oregon friends, Rebecca took it upon herself and posted flyers along the road to the 1996 Saginaw, Oregon convention grounds with Paul Ginestar’s photo on them, and also walked up and down the road to alert those who would talk to her about the potential danger of a child molester being on the convention grounds. Her parents and sibling packed up and left immediately. The local paper heard about Rebecca’s actions and wrote an article. Overseer Harold Bennett was quoted, “That person has been causing us a lot of difficulties, so we’re not interested in anything connected to her…We’re not interested in any kind of article of any kind of association with her.”
Ginestar Rebecca_1996 Newsp Art.JPG.pdf
In August 1996, Rebecca requested a meeting with Overseer of Oregon Harold Bennett and other Workers and Friends who were interested in discussing how to take protective measures so other young girls would not become victims of her father. She asked Chester Ehrig to facilitate the meeting, since she felt she would be too emotional. Instead, John Sterling and Tom Hinkle came; they refused to take any action because they “didn’t have the authority” to do so. Their concern was mainly to support Paul Ginestar’s continued attendance at meetings (for his own salvation). Ron & Wonlyn Chapman attended and wrote a detailed summary of the meeting.
By the time Rebecca was prepared to take her father to court, the statute of limitations had expired. Paul and Helen Ginestar subsequently moved to Utah, where he was made the elder of a meeting which included children. It is our understanding none of the families were warned that Ginestar had committed crimes against children.
Please read the full account of Rebecca’s heartbreaking story. It is a lengthy but an important read: https://ex2x2.info/2023/05/18/ginestar-rebecca-2/
Rebecca died of cancer in 2013. She was 44 years old. Paul Ginestar died in 2021.
ROBERT CORFIELD
1994/1996 – Michael Havet confided in some 2×2 friends about his abuse as a child over the span of many years by worker Robert Corfield. His friends told him he needed to tell Dale Shultz or they would tell him. They reported to Shultz, and a meeting was arranged to take place between Michael and Shultz at a convention grounds. Michael, who was around 25 years old at the time, drove to the grounds to attend the meeting. When he showed up for his meeting with Shultz, he was shocked and horrified to see his abuser, Robert Corfield, in attendance, along with another worker, Bob Covlin. The brother workers had water and they offered none to Michael during the hours-long meeting.
Michael was forced to confront Corfield, who took responsibility for his abuse of Michael. He also admitted that he had sexual relationships with some of his companions. Shultz and Covlin consoled Corfield. As the three brother workers sat across the room from Michael, Covlin told Michael, who was 12 years old when the abuse started, that he was dirty and made other comments attributing fault to him.
Shultz told Michael he was never to speak of the abuse. He stated, “It’s not a problem – it was just you.”
Shortly after Michael disclosed his abuse, a group of the friends was meeting Dale Shultz’s brother, Lyle Shultz, at the Regina Airport to welcome him back to Canada from his travels. Dale Shultz had learned that Michael had spoken with a trusted friend about the abuse he had endured, as that friend called Shultz about the abuse. When Shultz saw Michael that day at the airport, he grabbed him by the front of the shirt and slammed him up against a concrete post, splitting the back of Michael’s head open. Shultz yelled at Michael, “I told you not to talk to anybody!”
1997 – Corfield was sent to “labor” in Montana.
1999 – Corfield sent Michael a letter from Montana. Michael was livid to think of Corfield having access to kids in Montana. Sometime between 2000 and 2004, Michael contacted Montana Overseer Jack Price and disclosed his abuse by Corfield. According to Jack Price at the time, he had not been informed that Corfield was a confessed pedophile. Michael told Price that he either needed to get Corfield into counseling, or he was reporting to law enforcement. Corfield 1999 Letter to Havet.pdf
Sometime after Michael reported to Jack Price, Shultz approached Michael and told him he didn’t think “The Truth” was the place for Michael. Michael took that to mean he was no longer welcome in meetings and therefore excommunicated.
2004 – Corfield wrote Michael a letter thanking him for disclosing his abuse to Jack Price. 2004 Letter from Robert Corfield to Mike Havet (1)_Redacted (1).pdf
2005 – Corfield wrote Michael another letter to let him know he was treating with professing therapist Denise Kirkpatrick, and he is making a list of his victims. He requested Michael’s help
and participation in his treatment. The letter includes a Health Record Authorization from Denise Kirkpatrick. Even though Jack Price and Denise Kirkpatrick knew Corfield was a confessed pedophile and was staying in people’s homes with full access to children, they did not report Corfield to the authorities.
2005 Corfield Letter to Havet.pdf
Health Record Authorization – Denise KirkpatrickMichael Havet (1)_Redacted.pdf
2023 – Corfield was removed from the work when the child sex abuse crisis was disclosed and he is currently under investigation by the RCMP and the FBI.
BRUCE WADDELL
2010 – Convicted of child sexual assault stemming from an incident on a seven-year-old child in 2004. After the trial, Waddell admitted that there were other victims.
Waddell was removed from the work less than two years after the offense. When the Manitoba Overseer was asked by family for the reasons for his removal, Alton Mose stated that it was for health reasons. He was sent out of the province to Saskatoon, where no one was informed of his crime. He was enrolled in therapy for paraphilia around 2005.
Some workers were aware of Waddell’s crimes and pleaded with the Overseers to send Waddell back to Manitoba to face prosecution. After his trial, Waddell told reporters that it was his therapist who encouraged him to turn himself in, which he did.
All of this was kept secret until the public trial could no longer cover it up.
One of Waddell’s survivors wrote a short book on their repeated abuse by Waddell. About 200 copies of this went out to workers and others who were considered “need to know.” While there were several female workers and one male worker who responded with compassion by email, the only visible reaction was when 18 months later a worker took copies to a therapist to get advice on how to help, although no action resulted.
The Overseer, Mike Hassett, claimed he wanted to meet with the survivor alone, but declined when the survivor insisted that the spouse also attend.
When the survivor alluded to this in Didsbury convention testimony, the mic was quickly turned off so that the congregation could not hear it. Hassett was in attendance and is believed to be behind trying to shut the victim down. More cover up.
One witness describes Waddell’s crimes as starting in the 1960’s and personally knows 15 victims, both boys and girls, suggesting potentially hundreds of offenses. The probability that cover ups existed for decades is highly likely. https://wingsfortruth.info/breaking-the-silence-2/convicted-csa-ca-offenders/bruce-waddell/
TIM SEVERUD
MINNESOTA –
2007 – A 2×2 father in a Minnesota home where Severud, a younger brother worker, was staying, walked in on Severud sexually abusing his daughter. The father ordered Severud out of his home and called his sister who was a sister worker. She immediately reported it.
Subsequently, after agonizing over the situation, Lyle Schober, the Minnesota overseer, urged Severud to turn himself in, and he did so and was incarcerated. The friends were not notified that Severud had been arrested for child sex abuse. The young children of a former 2×2 couple had previously visited their 2×2 grandparents while Severud had been staying with them. They became concerned that there might be other children Severud had abused who might need therapy.
The mother reached out to Cherie Kropp, and together they drafted an “example notification letter.” Subsequently, both parents (with Ex-2×2 Scott Ross as a witness) met with Schober. They expressed their concern to Schober and informed him that if he did not send out a similar notification to ALL the friends in Minnesota, they would do so themselves. They gave him three days to decide before they would act. Lyle used the letter almost verbatim and sent it in a timely manner. To our knowledge, it was the first child sex abuse notification letter of its kind to be distributed statewide in the United States. Not long after that incident, six advocates formed WINGS for Truth.
Please read the letter for yourselves. It is an excellent letter and we believe this notification system should have been used for all abuse cases going forward. https://wingsfortruth.info/breaking-the-silence-2/letters-to-friends-and-workers/lyle-schober/
Severud was convicted of child sex abuse and incarcerated for five years, from 2007 to 2012. https://wingsfortruth.info/breaking-the-silence-2/convicted-csa-ca-offenders/tim-severud/
JEROME FRANDLE – BILL DENK
MICHIGAN:
2010 – Bro worker Darren Briggs was sentenced to 180 days in jail + probation for molesting a young boy in 2006.
Reportedly, his co-worker, Bill Denk drove Darren to meet Michigan Overseer Jerome Frandle who then drove Darren across state lines to Niagara Falls where Darren’s parents picked him up.
2010 – Bro worker Peter Mousseau was sentenced from 2 to 10 yrs in prison for sexually abusing 2 girls between 8 & 13 yrs in 1993 and 1997.
2011, Sept 16 – Overseer of MI, Jerome Frandle sent out a notification letter to MI workers and friends about Briggs and Mousseau.
Frandle & Denk failed to report the CSA to authorities and were both arrested. Jerome’s pre-trial defense was that Jerome was not a minister or clergy. An absurd representation from someone in his position as OVERSEER of Michigan Frandle claimed he didn’t know his lawyer was going to use that defense. One of the friends did an excellent job testifying against that defense. The judge ruled from the bench that Frandle absolutely was a minister/clergy. Not a typical ruling for a hearing like that.
Frandle, Jerome Michigan Hearing Transcript.pdf
2012, July – Jerome Frandle pleaded no contest and was sentenced to 100 hrs of community service plus $200 fine and 4 days in jail—which was commuted to community service.
2013, July – A year later, Bill Denk was convicted on the same charges and received the same sentence.
2013, July 28 – Bill Denk wrote a notification letter to friends & workers about their convictions. https://wingsfortruth.info/bill-denk-2013/
JOHAN MARAIS
1983 – A nine-year-old girl was sexually abused by worker Johan Marais in South Africa.
2010 – The survivor came forward and disclosed her abuse to Overseers Duane Hopkins, Trevor Loechel, Andy Robijn, Johan Kotze, and Dale Shultz. She also confronted Marais in writing, and he admitted the abuse. After persistence by the survivor’s advocates, Marais was removed from the work. He is currently the elder of a Sunday morning meeting and it is our understanding his home is also used for gospel meetings.
2012 – Leroy Lerwick wrote the following letter to the survivor and her family, advocating for Marais’ return to the work in South America. In the letter he also admits the international movement of workers who are prohibited from being on staff in other countries.
Due to the length of Lerwick’s letter, here are some excerpts of those admissions as well as an excerpt of extreme spiritual abuse:
- “Where did these workers come from? USA, Europe, Canada, South Africa, Australia, Korea. Who were they? They were fragile human vessels that God was able to use.”
- “A few had not done well, and their testimony was such that they were not free to continue in the work in their home country. Many would have thought they should not have a place in the work anywhere.”
- “One such brother from Switzerland was given the opportunity to go to Peru, and we now can see that God’s hand was in that arrangement, as he was the man with the courage and strength that was required to go to the high mountains to an area known for its violence, where even the police did not venture.”
- “I did not know what was behind those tears at the time, as no one spoke of his past and few in South America knew. He had committed a serious error and it had been undisclosed for years. Eventually it came to light and it was decided and correctly so that he should not be in the work in his country. However he pleaded for an opportunity to go to some country to pioneer, anywhere, no matter how difficult, and it was arranged for him to go to Peru.”
- “Another brother who did not manage to maintain a good testimony was the first to go to a country in the Caribbean, a very poor country where none had ventured to go.”
- “We pray that Johan could be restored to a useful place in South America even if he cannot and should not be active on the staff in his home country. Nothing matters but salvation, and the salvation of many is at stake. Finally, our humble plea is that in the interest of souls crying out who can help us, in these needy fields in South America, would you consider assuring the responsible brothers in South Africa that you would not object to Johan Marais helping in a field in South America, though he not be on the staff in South Africa. I am sure he is willing to spend the rest of his life in South America in the work and never return to his homeland if that were the conditions required of him. This is not a plea specifically in favor of Johan Marais, rather it is a plea on the behalf of souls that are destined to perish for lack of laborers. Your response will be appreciated.”
Please read Lerwick’s full letter and the survivor’s response to his letter here:
Letter to Barry Rany & Leroy, from A&M M.pdf
CHRIS CHANDLER
2014 – Chandler was convicted of child sexual abuse, which stemmed from an abuse that occurred several decades prior. It was also prior to his introduction to the 2×2 religion, where he subsequently became a minister.
There is evidence that Chandler disclosed his past to the overseers. He went back to the victim and apologized, and claimed that she accepted it and he considered the matter satisfactorily closed.
He was allowed full access to children, and even positioned himself as a child sex abuse advocate without disclosing his past. WINGS for Truth had contact with him and around 2012, had input from him in the development of a Code of Conduct. While his input didn’t form part of it, this is an example of a perpetrator hiding in plain sight, while the leadership knew about it. We have witness evidence that the crime was known by the leadership. Nothing was done about it, and no one was informed of his past.
As of today, there are no known allegations of offenses while a 2×2 worker.
https://wingsfortruth.info/breaking-the-silence-2/letters-to-friends-and-workers/chris-chandler-da vid-leitch/https://wingsfortruth.info/2023/05/07/chris-chandler-pleads-guilty/
MICHAEL PAYNE
2008 – Sister worker Claudia Toppin became aware of a serious allegation against brother worker Michael Payne, and subsequently contacted Lyle Schober and Craig Winquist. Following is a correspondence thread between the workers. The survivor was 14/15 years old at the time of the assault. Payne was a 41/42 year-old brother worker. The continued narrative by the workers is that advocates are lying about this assault. Read the correspondence here and decide for yourself: Michael Payne Correspondence (1).pdf
WALTER BURKINSHAW
2020 – A survivor came forward with allegations of child sex abuse against former Overseer Walter Burkinshaw. Burkinshaw eventually admitted to the abuse, documented in the following letter from Burkinshaw, which minimizes and downplays the abuse he admitted to, framing his crimes in a way that shifts attention away from the harm done to the victim and toward his own desire for forgiveness and reassurance. The letter also includes a subtle warning about defamation, even though defamation applies only to false statements. Letter from Walter Burkinshaw to Survivor.pdf
2021 – British Columbia overseer Merlin Affleck wrote the following letter to his staff regarding allegations against Walter Burkinshaw and Aaron Farough, a former worker who was later convicted on child pornography charges. Affleck’s letter claims that “it is important to be open, honest, and transparent,” yet Affleck immediately restricts sharing and scripting. Nowhere does he acknowledge the victim, address the seriousness of Burkinshaw’s admission, or express compassion for those harmed. Instead, responsibility for accountability and child protection is deferred to government agencies, distancing both leadership and the church from meaningful action. Affleck Letter 2021.pdf
There is no apparent empathy, apology, or visible concern for survivors. Burkinshaw has multiple allegations of child sex abuse.
Walter Burkinshaw and Aaron Farough are still in meetings with no apparent restrictions or measures in place to keep children safe.
Merlin Affleck remains the current overseer of British Columbia even though an allegation of child sexual abuse was reported against him to law enforcement in Canada as well as to the FBI.
LESLIE WHITE
Beginning in 2009, Beth and Tim Boelter began advocating on behalf of victims of Leslie White and pleading with Overseers to address his predatory behavior. During their advocacy, they learned that in Colorado, around the year 2000, a victim reported White to the workers for sexual assault. She plead with them to remove him from the ministry, so he did not eventually rape someone.
2010 – Beth and Tim received the attached letter from Duane Hopkins urging them to remain silent. duane hopkins response 3.2010 (1).pdf
2012, a sister worker accused White of raping her during preps at Elizabeth, Colorado, in 2003, when she was about 22 years old. She had been in the work for about two years and White was her Overseer.
He threatened her that if she ever spoke up, she would be put out of the work and out of meetings, and that no one would believe her—that they would believe him because of who he was. The atrocious handling of the allegation by the workers is covered in this document about the workers’ use of a fraudulent psychiatrist to question the survivor:
Post Regarding Professing Psychiatrist.pdf
The sister worker reported it to the Elbert County Sheriff’s Office in Colorado in 2012
White was removed from the work in 2012, and the sister worker was told that he would never be in the work again.
2013 – Beth Boelter was in conversation with another couple who were concerned about the lack of action taken by the ministry regarding White and were preparing a letter to Overseers. Here is Beth’s memo to that couple delineating known facts about White. Beth Memo Re Leslie White 9.14.13_Redacted.pdf
On November 1, 2013, that couple wrote a letter to Barry, Ray, and Lyle regarding Leslie White which states in part, “We are pleading with you to apologize to all who have been harmed or knowingly put in harm’s way by having been sent wolves in sheep’s clothing into their homes.
We are pleading with you to apologize to all the victims and their advocates who have been silenced, marginalized and even vilified for their concerns. We are pleading with you to do this publicly and openly, so that the trust in those in places of authority and responsibility can be confirmed and renewed.”
https://wingsfortruth.info/2023/07/02/a-pleading-voice-from-ten-years-ago/
2015 – White wrote an open letter to friends and workers stating it had been proven the allegations against him were false and he had been “cleared”. In turn, Sgt. Joel Heap of the Elbert County Sheriff’s Office wrote an open letter refuting White’s claims. Here is Sgt. Elbert’s letter: Letter from Sgt. Heap Elbert County SO.pdf
Please read this comprehensive collection of documentation regarding claims regarding Leslie White here, including statements from many survivors: https://ex2x2.info/2025/05/08/boelter-tim-beth/
2019 – A message appeared on an internet board indicating White was holding gospel meetings in Maine.
2023 – Overseer Ray Hoffmann admitted that White was helping him with gospel meetings in Maine, and it “wasn’t the best decision he had ever made,” and White’s preaching days once again came to an end. White died on November 7, 2025.
HOWARD CAMPBELL
1969 – Campbell was convicted a raping 19 year-old girl who was waiting to go into the work. He served time in prison. After his release, he was promoted to Elder with a meeting in his home.
1993 – A survivor came forward to workers with allegations of child sex abuse against Campbell. No appropriate legal or moral actions were taken.
2003 – Additional allegations of child sex abuse are reported to the workers against Campbell. At that time, Campbell was no longer allowed to take part, but the meetings were still held in his home. Again, no appropriate legal or moral actions were taken. In fact, quite the opposite as the following letters from Ed Alexander clearly show. While this was playing out between the workers and the perpetrator, the victims were silenced, shunned, victim blamed, and their salvation was weaponized.
In Alexander’s letter he explains, “I am sorry that I didn’t make it clear from the beginning that one of the reasons that we were so insistent that you see a professional counselor was that we, as ministers of our fellowship, have a legal responsibility to report any cases of sexual abuse that we are aware of. If we do not we can be prosecuted for failure to report a sexual crime. You can understand that we love our people very much and don’t want to report their misdeeds to the authorities, so the way we have usually complied with the law is by asking the offender to see a professional counselor. Then the counselor is required by law to report the incident, and we have fulfilled our legal responsibility by having insisted that the person get counseling. I know that I did not make this fact clear to you in our visits, and am sorry for any confusion that this may have caused. We did cover it obliquely, though, as there were several times that you mentioned that if you saw a counselor it would mean that you would go back to prison, and my reply each time was, that if that was the price to be right then I felt that you needed to be willing for that.”
Please read the Ed Alexander letters for yourselves:
Ed Alexander Letter to Howard Campbell -Redacted.pdf
DEAN BRUER
In 2023, Oregon Overseer Doyle Smith sent a letter to his staff, instructing them to share – at their discretion – that it had been determined that the late Oregon Overseer Dean Bruer had been accused of child sexual abuse and rape. The disclosure was quickly circulated online,
marking a turning point in bringing public attention to the child sexual abuse and sexual assault crisis within the 2×2 church. Consistent with the ministry’s longstanding approach, controlling the flow of information and making sure the information didn’t “get into the wrong hands” remained a central concern.
Below are links to Doyle Smith’s letters to his staff leading up to the release of the Bruer disclosure letter, as well as the disclosure letter itself.
Doyle Smith March 19, 2023 Letter to Staff.pdf
Doyle Smith March 21, 2023 Letter to Staff.pdf
Doyle Smith March 22, 2023 Letter to Staff.pdf