Complicity to Crimes Against Children


two little girls walking down a path holding hands

Complicity in the Church: A Call for Accountability and True Understanding of Scripture

Child sexual abuse within our fellowship is now revealed and a grievous reality for us. I believe its been compounded by a culture of complicity that enables wrongdoing to go unchecked. We have been indoctrinated to love and respect  our workers above all else. As well-meaning Christians—driven by respect for authority, loyalty to church leaders, or fear of causing division—unknowingly contributed to the very system that perpetuated abuse. I for one, will not be complicit now that I know about these egregious crimes against the innocent and vulnerable among us. How did this happen? I believe there is misunderstood and misused Scripture that has been used out of context leading us to support harmful behavior when we believe we are acting in faith. Understanding the nature of this complicity and addressing it through genuine accountability is essential if we are to create a safe, Christ-centered community.

How Complicity Thrives in Misinterpretation

The Bible offers countless teachings on respect, submission, forgiveness, and unity within the church. Verses like Hebrews 13:17 (“Obey your leaders and submit to their authority”) and Ephesians 4:3 (“Make every effort to keep the unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace”) are often used to encourage members to support their leaders. These verses are essential for creating harmony in the church, yet when applied without discernment, they can become tools for silencing valid concerns and hiding serious misconduct. When teachings on forgiveness are misunderstood as a call to avoid confrontation or accountability, abuse victims may feel pressured to “forgive and forget,” while perpetrators evade justice.

In our conservative and  fundamentalist fellowship, this dynamic is intensified by strict interpretations of authority and an environment where questioning leadership is not only frowned upon but hardly an option. We have submitted to a fear-based culture that raising issues—especially involving respected workers—will disrupt the church or bring shame upon the faith. In seeking to avoid division, we unwittingly created a culture where abuse is hidden and where victims are left unprotected. Over time, this complicit behavior, even if unintended, allowed abuse to continue unchecked and harmed the very people Jesus commanded us to protect.

Every worker, elder or friend who was or is aware of these hidden cases of child abuse—whether within their ranks or among those attending meetings—yet chose to remain silent, shares in the responsibility. Their silence makes them complicit, and they bear part of the guilt for the harm done to children.

Why Do We Stay Complicit?

There are several reasons why complicity in abuse cases remains so prevalent in church communities:

1. Fear of Disrupting Unity

We view the church as a refuge and a place of peace and we dearly love our ministry.  We may avoid speaking out to preserve unity, mistakenly thinking that silence is a sign of spiritual maturity. However, true unity is only possible when truth and justice are upheld. By remaining silent in the face of abuse, we may believe we are fostering peace, but in reality, we are allowing a culture of harm to continue unchecked. 

2. Misplaced Loyalty to Leadership  

In our conservative and fundamentalist culture, we often hold workers in high esteem as figures of spiritual authority. We felt compelled to support them unconditionally, equating loyalty to them with faithfulness to God. However, the Bible clearly teaches that all leaders are fallible and must be held accountable. When our loyalty to leaders supersedes our loyalty to God’s values, it can lead us to defend wrongdoing blindly, compromising the very principles we seek to uphold.

3. Misinterpretation of Forgiveness 

Forgiveness is central to Christianity, but it is not a mandate to avoid justice or overlook harmful behavior. True forgiveness doesn’t negate accountability—it encourages a transformation that requires recognition of wrongdoing and a commitment to make amends. Misunderstanding forgiveness can lead some to minimize the experiences of abuse victims, viewing calls for justice as “unforgiving” or “unchrist-like.” (For more information on misuse of forgiveness on perpetrators see Forgivness, Forbearance & Misuse)

4. Fear of Being Judged as Rebellious 

In our circles, raising difficult issues can lead to accusations of divisiveness or rebellion. In fact, we have been conditioned not to question anything! We may worry that speaking out will isolate us from our community or brand us as troublemakers because we have witnessed this happening to others if they dared say something about a problem they were concerned about.  This fear can prevent well-intentioned people from holding leaders accountable, especially when speaking out could lead to personal, relational, or social repercussions.

5. Trusting in the System Over Scripture 

In our fellowship, we have developed a cultural hierarchy where leaders are often seen as beyond reproach, and the system itself is trusted more than the teachings of Christ. This reliance on “church culture” over Scripture has led us to overlook the Bible’s clear calls for justice and the protection of the vulnerable, creating a cycle in which accountability is scarce and silence is the standard. This distortion of priorities not only betrays our core beliefs but also allows harm to persist unchecked, contrary to the very heart of Christ’s message.

The Biblical Call for Accountability and Justice

Scripture is abundantly clear about our responsibility to protect and advocate for the vulnerable. Jesus Himself said, “Whoever welcomes one such child in my name welcomes me” (Matthew 18:5) and issued a stern warning against causing harm to children (Matthew 18:6). The Bible consistently emphasizes justice, calling us to “defend the weak and the fatherless” (Psalm 82:3) and to “act justly and love mercy” (Micah 6:8). These verses, far from suggesting passive obedience, call for active engagement in promoting righteousness and protecting those at risk.

The early church also established principles for accountability. When leaders acted contrary to the Gospel, they were openly corrected (Galatians 2:11-14). The apostle Paul encouraged believers to test everything and hold fast to what is good (1 Thessalonians 5:21), a call for discernment that includes evaluating church practices and leadership actions. The Bible encourages believers to stand up against wrongdoing within the church, seeking truth and justice as an expression of love for both God and neighbor.

Toward a Solution: Building a Culture of Transparency and Safety

To overcome complicity, we must foster a culture that values transparency, accountability, and the safety of all members, particularly children. Here are practical steps toward achieving this:

1. Re-Evaluate Church Culture on Authority and Accountability  

Overseers and workers alike should provide balanced teachings that emphasize accountability alongside respect for leadership. Leaders are called to serve humbly, not to wield authority without question. A biblically sound perspective on authority and accountability will encourage us to speak up when they witness harm without fear of condemnation. Maybe committee’s of elders and friends could be appointed to make these decisions and hold workers accountable when necessary? Women should be on the committee’s. Just saying! We are the mothers who raise the kids and hopefully produce good humans. We look at things differently than men do. 


2. Cultivate a Compassionate, Listening Community

Since workers failed miserably at listening to the survivors, we, the sheep, must be willing to listen compassionately to those who raise concerns, especially survivors of abuse. By fostering a culture where victims are heard and supported, we can offer a safe place for healing rather than a space of fear and silence within the church. 

3. Provide Education on Forgiveness and Justice

Churches can hold workshops or Bible studies that explore the true nature of forgiveness and justice, emphasizing that forgiveness does not mean dismissing accountability. Teaching members the biblical basis for justice can empower them to advocate for victims without feeling as though they are being unchristian. This also could be a committee of friends who educate. 

4. Implement Strong Safeguards and Reporting Mechanisms 

Establishing clear protocols for reporting abuse and ensuring that these reports are taken seriously is essential for any church community including ours. Independent review boards and external oversight can also prevent internal biases from silencing victims or ignoring allegations. 

5. Encourage Spiritual Discernment and Courage

Encourage our friends to practice spiritual discernment, knowing that it’s biblical to test leadership and call out wrongdoing. Encourage them to pray for courage and wisdom, and to remember that loyalty to Christ comes before loyalty to any human leader.

 A Call to Act

Ending complicity in the church starts with a commitment to Christ’s teachings on justice, mercy, and protection of the innocent. Silence, apathy, or passive submission may seem easier, but they only perpetuate cycles of harm. Instead, we are called to be active participants in God’s work of reconciliation and healing, which requires a willingness to confront sin and demand accountability.

Our mission as a church is not just to preach the Gospel, but to live it—by embodying Christ’s compassion and dedication to truth. As Christians, we have a duty to confront injustice, even when it occurs within our own walls. Only through a culture of transparency, compassion, and accountability can we create a community that truly reflects the love, safety, and integrity of Christ.

– Rhonda Grillo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *