Rock ‘n Roll, Legalism, and Learning to Listen to the Holy Spirit
I’ll never forget the day I was caught red-handed—not stealing, not lying, not committing some great moral failure—but doing something that, in our home, was considered just as bad.
I was listening to Rock ‘n Roll music.
Now, let’s be clear—I loved music. I played the piano almost every day. I cherished our classical records. Music was, and still is, a huge part of who I am.
But then… at fifteen years old, I discovered the radical sin of radio.
I bought my first car—a junker I affectionately named Buela, because honestly, she was held together by prayer and duct tape. And with Buela came something life-changing…
📻 THE RADIO.
I’ll never forget the first time I cranked up the volume in my car, fully immersing myself in the forbidden beats.
🎸 Rock ‘n Roll—full volume.
🎶 It was the good stuff—the 70s and 80s era when music actually had soul!
🕺 I was practically dancing in my seat… but dancing was also a sin, so I restrained myself.
My eyes were closed, my whole being engulfed in the rhythm, completely unaware of the doom creeping toward me.
Because while I was lost in the ecstasy of forbidden sound waves, my parents had pulled into the garage.
🚨 BANG, BANG, BANG! 🚨
I nearly had a heart attack. My eyes POPPED open.
I turned to see my mother, her face contorted in absolute disgust and disappointment, pounding on my car door.
Her look said it all—horror, dismay, and deep spiritual concern.
I had been caught in the act of blatant worldliness.
And I was ashamed.
Why Music Was Such a Battleground in Legalism
Looking back, I can understand why the Workers were so strict about TV, music and entertainment in general. We weren’t allowed to go to High School football games. We weren’t allowed to play in sports. So many rules.
They genuinely cared about us. They wanted us to be right with God.
To them, salvation was something that had to be earned, and that meant eliminating anything that might pull us away from holiness—including music with worldly influences.
And my mother? She adored them. She hung on every word they said because her heart was in the right place. She wanted what was best for us. She wanted to make sure we made it to heaven.
She wasn’t trying to be controlling. She was trying to protect us.
And honestly? They weren’t entirely wrong about music’s influence.
Because music does shape our thoughts, emotions, and behaviors.
Neuroscience: How Music Rewires the Brain
Science has confirmed what the Workers instinctively feared—music is powerful.
🧠 Music activates multiple areas of the brain. It engages the amygdala (emotions), hippocampus (memory), and prefrontal cortex (decision-making).
🧠 Lyrics bypass logic and program the subconscious. The more we repeat something, the more our brains accept it as truth. That’s why you can remember song lyrics from 20 years ago, but not what you had for dinner last night.
🧠 Rhythm and repetition reinforce beliefs. That’s why advertisers use catchy jingles—because music imprints deeply into the brain.
So, were the Workers right to be cautious? Yes, to a degree.
Not because all music is evil but because lyrics and repetition influence our thought patterns.
The Bible confirms this:
“Above all else, guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it.” (Proverbs 4:23)
Music isn’t just entertainment—it’s mental and spiritual programming.
The Right and Wrong of Legalism
Where legalism went wrong was not in teaching caution but in removing personal discernment.
Legalism says:
❌ All secular music is bad.
❌ Avoid it at all costs.
❌ Following rules is how we stay right with God.
But Spirit-led discernment says:
✅ Music is powerful—use wisdom in what you listen to.
✅ Be mindful of lyrics and their impact on your thoughts.
✅ Holiness isn’t about following rules—it’s about following Christ.
The Pharisees fell into the same trap:
“You clean the outside of the cup and dish, but inside you are full of greed and self-indulgence.” (Matthew 23:25)
They focused so much on external holiness that they missed the point entirely.
And for a long time, we did too.
How I Raised My Kids Differently
After years of fear-based rule-following, I made a decision.
I would not pass that on to my children.
We listened to music.
We watched movies.
We went to concerts.
We went to high school games.
But we did it with discernment, not legalism.
💡 We honored the Spirit within us. If a song, movie, or magazine made us uncomfortable spiritually, we stopped. Not because a Worker said so—but because we learned to recognize God’s voice for ourselves.
💡 We didn’t live with a “hide it when the Workers come over” mentality. If something was okay in private, it was okay in public—because integrity means being the same person in all circumstances.
💡 We evaluated content by its fruit, not its genre. It wasn’t about Christian vs. Secular—it was about truth vs. deception, light vs. darkness, life-giving vs. destructive.
And you know what?
🎶 My kids still love Jesus.
🎶 They never went off the deep end.
🎶 They never had to unlearn toxic guilt.
Because they learned discernment—not fear-based obedience.
Final Thoughts: Jesus, Not Legalism, Is the Standard
The Workers truly cared about us—they wanted to keep us on the right path.
My mother genuinely wanted what was best for us—she followed their advice because her heart was in the right place.
But holiness was never meant to be about rules—it was meant to be about relationship.
And at the end of the day, my Rock ‘n Roll moment didn’t lead me into sin—it led me into awareness.
Awareness that God is bigger than man-made rules.
Awareness that truth isn’t dictated by tradition.
Awareness that the Holy Spirit—not fear—should guide us.
So, to my fifteen-year-old self, rocking out in Buela in that garage…
I wish I could go back and say:
🚀 “Turn up the volume, girl. You’re not sinning. Just use wisdom, honor God, and enjoy the gift of music.”
And maybe—just maybe—throw in a little dancing for good measure. 🎸🔥
Rhonda Grillo