By Rhonda Grillo, Founder of Bridging the GAP on CSA
For many, the word “church” evokes images of a sanctuary—a place of worship, safety, healing, and belonging.
But what happens when the sanctuary is no longer safe?
What happens when wolves are allowed to roam freely among the sheep?
This is the dilemma facing the 2×2 church today, as decades of hidden child sexual abuse (CSA) are being dragged into the light.
And it demands that we confront a question many would rather avoid:
Should known predators be allowed to continue attending church gatherings?
At first glance, the question itself feels jarring.
Aren’t all sinners welcome? Doesn’t grace extend to everyone?
Yes—grace is extended to all.
But grace does not negate justice.
And forgiveness does not erase consequences.
In fact, Scripture is abundantly clear that leadership, fellowship, and influence inside the body of Christ are not automatic rights.
They are privileges tied to repentance, accountability, and fruit-bearing change.
Jesus Himself warned us to beware of wolves in sheep’s clothing (Matthew 7:15).
Paul urged the early church to expel the immoral brother (1 Corinthians 5:11-13) when sin—especially sexual sin—was left unaddressed.
When a predator has demonstrated the willingness to violate trust and destroy innocence, it is not unloving to protect the vulnerable from further harm.
It is the highest form of love.
Allowing predators to sit undetected among families, survivors, and children is not compassion—it is complicity.
It sends a chilling message to the wounded:
“Your safety is not our priority. Your healing is not our concern.”
The Cost of Pretending
In the 2×2 church, the cost of silence and misplaced grace has been devastating.
- Survivors have been retraumatized by sharing worship space with their abusers.
- Children have been unknowingly exposed to danger under the false assumption that everyone attending meetings was “safe.”
- The reputation of Christ has been tarnished by leaders who confused “keeping the peace” with protecting predators.
The early church understood what we seem to have forgotten:
A little leaven leavens the whole lump (Galatians 5:9).
When sin—especially predatory sin—is tolerated in the camp, it poisons the entire community.
Holiness is not about perfection; it’s about separation from evil.
And true restoration—should it ever occur—demands visible, verifiable fruit of repentance, including a willingness to accept appropriate boundaries.
Boundaries Are Not Bitterness
Excluding predators from regular church attendance is not bitterness.
It is biblical boundary-setting designed to protect the vulnerable.
A predator is welcome to pursue God—but that does not entitle them to unrestricted access to His people, especially those they have harmed.
True repentance embraces accountability; it does not resent it.
- If a predator is genuinely repentant, they will not demand unsupervised access to gatherings.
- They will not manipulate Scripture to gain proximity to potential victims.
- They will accept safeguards without resistance, understanding that their actions forfeited certain privileges.
As Paul wrote to the Corinthians, the loving response to unrepentant sin is clear:
“Hand this man over to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, so that his spirit may be saved on the day of the Lord.” (1 Corinthians 5:5)
The goal is not revenge—it is redemption.
But redemption cannot happen while enabling continues.
The Question We Must Answer
So we return to the original question:
Should predators be allowed to attend church?
And a deeper one:
What kind of church are we trying to be?
A church that prioritizes image over integrity?
Or a church that mirrors the heart of Christ, who fiercely protected the vulnerable and rebuked those who would cause “one of these little ones to stumble” (Matthew 18:6)?
We are called to be shepherds—not hirelings.
We are called to guard the flock—not leave the gate open in the name of “forgiveness.”
It is time for the 2×2 church—and every church—to decide:
Will we be a safe place for survivors?
Or a hiding place for predators?
We cannot be both.