Breaking Free from Legalism and Finding the Heart of Holiness
From Eyeliner to Eternity: How I Learned Worldliness Wasn’t About Sparkles
I used to think “worldliness” lurked behind every eyeliner pencil and magazine rack.
As a girl raised in a strict religious environment, I was taught that wearing pants, trimming your hair, or adorning yourself with anything remotely sparkly was basically a gateway drug to moral collapse. You didn’t go to concerts. You didn’t play sports. And you definitely didn’t read People magazine in the dentist’s office—because apparently, even your molars needed to be protected from worldly influence.
That was the theology: salvation by extreme naivety and over-the-top hygiene. Not really, but sometimes I just have to be snarky. My mom loved us and she did the very best she knew how.
But somewhere along the line, I started reading the actual Bible instead of the invisible rulebook handed down by tradition.
And guess what? It didn’t say any of that.
In high-control environments like the Two by Twos, “worldliness” wasn’t a matter of the heart—it was a visual checklist. If it looked modern, expressive, or joyful, it was suspect. The message wasn’t “guard your heart,” it was “guard your hemline, your hairdo, and for heaven’s sake, your playlist–records back then.”
Holiness got hijacked by appearances. And, salvation started to feel like a fashion show where God was the front-row judge with a clipboard and no sense of humor.
Then I Became a Mom. And Something Shifted.
I didn’t want my kids to grow up fearing fashion or fun. I wanted them to fear missing out on a relationship with the God who made them.
So I raised them differently than I was raised.
Instead of handing them a list of “thou shalt nots,” I taught them to walk with the Holy Spirit. I told them their soul came from God—and one day, it would return to Him.
That made their life sacred.
That made their choices matter.
Not because of a rigid checklist, but because their soul was worth protecting.
But here’s the difference: I didn’t tell them magazines were portals to perdition. I taught them to pray for discernment. I reminded them that God promises wisdom to anyone who asks for it—and that He’d guide them as they made choices about books, music, movies, friends, fashion, and yes—even in dating.
My mom did her very best to protect us. I appreciate that now. But back then? Let’s just say that getting grounded for secretly listening to rock ‘n’ roll in my car felt… a bit extra.
Discernment Isn’t a Dress Code—It’s a Dialogue
My kids grew up learning how to pause, pray, and pay attention to the still, small voice within. They knew the goal wasn’t perfection—it was relationship. Not rule-following for approval, but walking in wisdom with a God who delights in connection.
And guess what?
They grew into wise, thoughtful adults who can think both critically and spiritually—without being terrified that jeans, joy, or a catchy beat were going to get them kicked out of heaven.
Turns out, the Holy Spirit is a better guide than fear. And freedom in Christ doesn’t come with a dress code—it comes with discernment.
And that’s a whole lot more liberating than any skirt length ever was.
What the Bible Actually Says About Worldliness
Let’s go to one of the most quoted (and most misused) Scriptures:
“Do not love the world or the things in the world. If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him.”
—1 John 2:15
Often, this was the go-to verse for banning everything from sports to lipstick. But let’s read the next part:
“For everything in the world—the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes, and the pride of life—comes not from the Father but from the world.”
—1 John 2:16
Notice what’s not on that list:
- Nail polish
- Jewelry
- Entertainment
- A magazine in the orthodontist’s lobby
According to Scripture, worldliness is:
- Lust of the flesh: giving in to destructive desires
- Lust of the eyes: constant craving for more
- Pride of life: puffed-up ego, status obsession, self-exaltation
It’s not about what’s in your closet.
It’s about what’s ruling your heart.
The Double Standard No One Wanted to Talk About
And let’s talk about the elephant in the fellowship hall—or should I say, the dress code in the women’s closet.
For all the talk about “worldliness,” it’s painfully clear that most of the rules targeted women. We were scrutinized for skirt lengths, hair styles, and jewelry. Heaven forbid you wore your hair down—it might send someone down a spiritual spiral. Meanwhile, as long as the men kept their hair short and their shirts tucked in, they were off the hook. No one seemed concerned about their emotional maturity or abuse of their family.
But recently, the truth has started to come out. Porn addiction is a silent epidemic in our ranks, and it’s rarely addressed. Even more sobering? It’s now credibly estimated that nearly 40% of the child abuse occurred within the ministry itself. Yes—those very workers and leaders held up as “examples” of holiness.
So while women were being corrected for wearing a pair of pants, some of our spiritual authorities were violating the most sacred boundaries imaginable.
They weren’t protecting purity.
They were protecting appearances—at the cost of the innocent.
This is why we have to rethink everything.
Because real holiness doesn’t suppress women and ignore predators.
It doesn’t major in modesty while staying silent about molestation.
God never expected that.
Our leaders did though.
Jesus Didn’t Come to Enforce a Dress Code
If holiness could be achieved through plain outfits and approved “perfect” appearances such as wearing a very long skirt and our hair in a bun, the Pharisees would’ve been first in line for heaven. But Jesus wasn’t impressed.
“You clean the outside of the cup and dish, but inside you are full of greed and self-indulgence.”
—Matthew 23:25
He wasn’t calling out people who wore “worldly” sandals or beautiful robes. He was confronting hearts that cared more about looking righteous than being right with God.
Jesus never said, “They’ll know you’re mine by your muted wardrobe and somber expressions.”
He said:
“They’ll know you’re mine by your love.”
—John 13:35
And love isn’t loud about itself. It’s loud about truth, grace, justice, and compassion. All missing actions we have observed during this current CSA crisis.
Legalism: A Worldly System in Disguise
Here’s the irony: legalism is actually quite worldly.
Why? Because it feeds the very thing Scripture warns us about—the pride of life.
It turns spirituality into a performance:
- Look how obedient we are.
- Look how separated we are.
- Look how untouched by “the world” we are.
But when religion becomes about reputation over relationship, it’s no longer a path to God—it’s a costume party masking the ugliness within.
The Real Danger Isn’t Eyeliner—It’s Ego and Hypocrisy
We were told that if we wore jewelry, watched a movie, listened to “worldly” music or dyed our hair, the Holy Spirit might exit the premises. As if the Creator of the universe is so fragile He can’t handle a worship song with a guitar.
That wasn’t holiness—it was superstition wrapped in a fear bow.
“You foolish Galatians! Who has bewitched you? After beginning by means of the Spirit, are you now trying to finish by means of the flesh?”
—Galatians 3:1–3
Paul wasn’t speaking to pagans. He was speaking to deeply religious people who had traded grace for a checklist.
Sound familiar?
What Holiness Actually Looks Like
Biblical holiness is beautiful. It’s not about hiding who you are—it’s about being set apart by who He is.
“Do not conform to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind.”
—Romans 12:2
Holiness looks like:
- A heart that’s soft to God
- A life marked by love, truth, and mercy
- Standing for what’s right even when it’s hard
- Walking with discernment and humility in a noisy world
It’s not about having the “right” look. It’s about having a heart aligned with heaven.
Jesus Came to Set Us Free—Not Dress Us in Fear
If you’ve left legalism and still feel guilty for enjoying a peaceful, joyful, colorful life—let me reassure you:
You are not worldly. You’re finally free.
“It is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Stand firm, then, and do not let yourselves be burdened again by a yoke of slavery.”
—Galatians 5:1
Freedom in Christ doesn’t mean chaos. It means clarity. It means trusting the Holy Spirit to lead you—moment by moment, decision by decision.
You can wear color, enjoy beauty, laugh out loud, and still be set apart—because holiness was never about shrinking back.
It was about shining and sharing the gifts God created within you.
Don’t Confuse Control with Conviction
If something doesn’t sit right in your spirit, God will show you if you have a relationship with Him. You don’t need fear or shame to keep you aligned—you need a healthy relationship.
God’s guidance is peaceful, not panicked.
It’s specific, not vague.
It’s empowering, not paralyzing.
The Holy Spirit doesn’t need man-made rules to lead you in truth.
He just needs your trust and to be led, obedient to His guidance which will never contradict His Word.
The Takeaway: Worldliness Is a Heart Issue—Not a Hair Issue
Let’s stop measuring godliness by what we avoid and start defining it by what we pursue.
- Worldliness is loving anything more than God.
- Holiness is loving God so much that it shapes your life.
The Pharisees loved rules.
Jesus loved people.
Let’s follow Him.