Triggering Retraumatization: Why Discovering the Cover-Ups Can Set Survivors Back in Their Healing
For survivors of abuse, retriggers and retraumatization refer to the experience of being emotionally or physically thrown back into the overwhelming feelings and psychological state associated with the original trauma. This occurs when something in the present—often a memory, event, statement, or discovery—reminds the survivor of the abuse they suffered in the past. These triggers can cause a profound emotional and psychological response that mimics the original trauma, even though the event causing the trigger may not involve physical harm or direct danger.
How Trauma Works in the Brain: The Mechanisms of Retraumatization
When someone experiences abuse, particularly during childhood, their brain is flooded with stress hormones such as cortisol and adrenaline, which can alter their brain chemistry and affect memory, emotions, and overall well-being. The trauma becomes embedded in the survivor’s psyche, often at a subconscious level, and the body’s stress response system is permanently impacted. Even after the abuse has ended, the body and mind remain hypersensitive to reminders of the trauma.
The discovery of cover-ups and the perpetuation of abuse by those in power—especially in institutions like churches, schools, or even families—can be especially retraumatizing because it triggers the survivor’s deep sense of betrayal, violation of trust, and helplessness. When the abuse is exposed, the survivor may relive feelings of powerlessness and despair, reawakening the emotional and psychological wounds that had been healing.
Why Survivors Are Set Back in Their Healing Process
1. Revelation of Betrayal and Hopelessness:
Discovering that the abuse was not only ignored but covered up or perpetuated by trusted ministers or family members can feel like a second betrayal. Survivors often feel as though the very people they looked to for safety and support—priests, teachers, parents, or other authorities—were complicit in the harm done to them. The psychological effects of this betrayal are profound because it’s not just the abuse that’s revisited, but the broken trust and loss of faith in the religion that should have protected them. This reopens old wounds and often makes survivors feel alone and unprotected once again.
2. Re-exposure to Trauma:
When survivors learn about the cover-up or see the perpetrators being shielded from justice, it can trigger intrusive memories, flashbacks, or a flood of emotions that mirror the intensity of their original trauma. For example, survivors might feel like they are back in that moment of abuse, feeling the same fear, helplessness, or confusion. These emotional flashbacks are often intense and difficult to navigate, pulling the survivor out of their present reality and back into the pain of their past.
3. Revocation of a Sense of Justice:
Survivors often crave justice and acknowledgment for the harm they’ve endured. When they discover that the abuse was covered up, it can feel as though they were denied justice for a second time. For many, the idea of justice being ignored or swept under the rug can be psychologically devastating, especially when the system that should have protected them instead empowered the abusers. This loss of hope in seeing wrongs righted can be deeply demoralizing, leading survivors to feel as though their pain is not worthy of acknowledgment or redress. This can intensify feelings of rejection, diminish self-worth and confidence, and amplify other discouraging emotions.
4. Physical and Mental Health Setbacks:
The emotional pain caused by retraumatization can also manifest physically. Chronic stress, anxiety depression, PTSD, and somatic symptoms (like headaches, stomach issues, or muscle tension) are common responses. Many survivors experience physical relapses in their mental health due to the intensity of the emotional reaction triggered by these new revelations. Their body’s stress response system can become overwhelmed, disrupting their sleep patterns, appetite, and overall well-being. They may experience panic attacks, nightmares, or flashbacks that were previously managed or mitigated.
5. The Shame of Silence and Silence of Others:
Survivors can feel immense shame not only about the abuse itself but about the culture of silence that allows such abuse to persist. The fact that others knew or suspected what was happening, yet chose to stay silent or allow the abuse to continue, can reignite feelings of shame and guilt. These emotions are compounded by the fact that many survivors often blame themselves for not speaking out sooner or for not preventing the abuse, even though the responsibility lies squarely with the abusers and the system that protected them.
Why It Feels Like “Going Backwards” in Healing
Healing from trauma is a delicate, ongoing process. Many survivors experience what’s called non-linear healing, where progress may feel slow, and setbacks happen. Discovering that the abuse was not only a personal trauma but part of a larger, systemic failure can feel like taking two steps back. This setback doesn’t negate the healing that has already occurred; it simply opens up old wounds that need further care and attention. Survivors may feel isolated, frustrated, and disillusioned—and that can create further emotional damage if not addressed.
The Impact on Their Survival is Massive
For survivors, all of these compounded emotions, struggles and complications don’t exist in isolation; they often ripple out to affect many aspects of life. Challenges with self-esteem and trust can create obstacles in careers and business, where confidence and stability are crucial. In relationships, these feelings can lead to struggles with intimacy, vulnerability, and effective communication, sometimes resulting in a cycle of misunderstandings and conflict. The emotional toll of past trauma, left unaddressed, can disrupt almost every facet of a survivor’s life, creating barriers to the healing, connection, and success they deserve.
Survivors of child abuse often grapple with deep, unresolved pain that can lead to self-medicating and self-destructive behaviors as they seek ways to cope with overwhelming emotions. Many turn to alcohol, drugs, or other harmful habits to numb their pain, creating cycles of dependency that further erode their sense of control and self-worth. This tendency toward self-sabotage might also manifest as negative self-talk, neglecting personal needs, or engaging in risky behaviors, all of which reinforce the internalized belief that they are undeserving of care or stability. These coping mechanisms, though often seen as a form of escape, ultimately serve to deepen the wounds of abuse, making it even more challenging for survivors to break free from their past and move towards healing.
The Path Forward: What Helps Survivors Heal After Retraumatization?
1. Acknowledgment and Validation:
Acknowledging that retraumatization is real and that survivors’ feelings of anger, betrayal, sadness, and fear are legitimate is the first step toward healing. Validation of these emotions—whether through therapy, support groups, or trusted loved ones—is crucial. Survivors need to be reminded that their feelings are not just valid, but also that they are entitled to seek justice and to grieve what has been taken from them.
2. Creating Safety:
Survivors must feel safe in their environment in order to begin healing again. This might mean taking time away from triggers, like media coverage of the scandal or toxic environments that have perpetuated silence. This can also mean building a support system—friends, therapists, and groups who understand the unique needs of survivors. Boundaries are essential for healing, and survivors should have the freedom to set those boundaries in their own time.
3. Therapeutic Support:
Professional therapy, particularly trauma-informed therapy, can provide survivors with tools to process the retraumatization and begin healing again. Techniques such as EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) or cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) can be particularly helpful in addressing the emotional triggers and flashbacks that can occur during retraumatization. A life coaching is often effective as well.
4. Advocacy and Action:
For many survivors, taking action in the form of speaking out, advocating for change, or supporting justice initiatives can be empowering. Channeling the anger and frustration into advocacy work or victim support can help survivors regain a sense of control over their healing process, transforming the pain into purpose.
The Path to Recovery Is Not Linear
When survivors discover that their abuse was covered up or perpetuated, it can be a deeply retraumatizing experience. The emotions triggered by betrayal, silence, and systemic injustice can feel overwhelming and often bring up memories of the original trauma. It’s important to recognize that this retraumatization is part of a complex and painful process of healing, and the journey may involve periods of both progress and setbacks.
Survivors should not blame themselves for these emotional setbacks. Retriggering and retraumatization are natural responses to new revelations and reminders of past trauma. Healing, though, is still possible. Acknowledgment, support, and care are key to moving forward again, and while the journey may feel long, each step forward is still progress.
– Rhonda Grillo